A recent official letter from Morocco to UNESCO has reignited a simmering cultural dispute between Rabat and Algiers. In its correspondence, the Moroccan government denounces what it calls “inappropriate remarks” — including expressions such as “sons of Bousbir” and “Kingdom of Marrakech” — allegedly voiced by Algerian civil society during the evaluation of Morocco’s bid to inscribe the “Moroccan” Caftan on UNESCO’s Representative List of Intangible Cultural Heritage. Rabat accuses these actors of “political manipulation” and urges the organization to safeguard the integrity of its assessment process.
Yet behind this diplomatic exchange lies a far deeper controversy: the origins of the Caftan and the legitimacy of Morocco’s claim to register it as part of its national heritage. Algerian civil society, highly active in heritage advocacy, views Rabat’s move as a blatant act of cultural appropriation — particularly since the Caftan was already recognized in 2012 by UNESCO as an element of Algerian heritage.
The Algerian Precedent
In 2012, Algeria successfully inscribed the “Rites and know-how associated with the tradition of the female nuptial costume of Tlemcen” on UNESCO’s Representative List. This dossier explicitly included the Caftan (Lebset El Arftan) as a central component of the bridal attire, detailing its craftsmanship, ceremonial role, and symbolic significance. A subsequent submission in 2023 reinforced this heritage by highlighting ceremonial costumes from Eastern Algeria, once again featuring the Caftan.
A Heritage Rooted in Ottoman Legacy
Historically, the Caftan is inseparable from the Ottoman sartorial tradition. The Ottoman Empire never extended its influence to Morocco, but it profoundly shaped Algerian society, leaving indelible marks on its arts, customs, and attire. For Algerian experts, the notion of a “Moroccan Caftan” is a recent construct — a narrative driven by political and touristic ambitions rather than historical continuity.
Archival records and notarized documents from the 18th and 19th centuries attest to the Caftan’s prominence in Algerian urban centers such as Tlemcen, Constantine, Annaba, and Algiers. Worn during major ceremonies and passed down through generations, the Caftan symbolized dignity, refinement, and urban identity — a living testimony to Algeria’s Ottoman heritage.
Material and Artistic Evidence
Numerous historical Caftans are preserved in Algerian museums (such as the Bardo Museum and the Museum of Antiquities in Algiers) and in prestigious international collections, including the Royal Armory of Stockholm and the Imperial Palace of Vienna. Some were diplomatic gifts — for instance, a Caftan presented to the King of Sweden in 1731 and garments acquired by Empress Elisabeth of Austria in Tlemcen.
The Algerian Caftan is distinguished by intricate embroidery, notably the peacock motif — a symbol of royalty and spirituality — which permeates not only clothing but also ceramics, tapestries, paintings, poetry, and popular song. This iconography underscores the Caftan’s deep cultural resonance within Algerian identity.
A Cultural Battle with Geopolitical Undertones
This dispute transcends fashion. It reflects a broader rivalry between two nations vying for cultural primacy in the Maghreb. Each UNESCO inscription becomes a symbolic asset, a tool of soft power. For Morocco, branding the Caftan as Moroccan enhances its cultural allure and global image. For Algeria, defending the authenticity of its heritage is a matter of historical integrity and national pride.
UNESCO now faces a delicate challenge: adjudicating without exacerbating tensions. If the Representative List of Intangible Heritage devolves into a diplomatic battleground, it risks betraying its founding purpose — fostering cultural cooperation and celebrating diversity.
By Belgacem Merbah
Comments
Post a Comment