Algeria–France Crisis: A Long-Foreseen Fracture According to Algerian Diplomats in Paris

For several months now, relations between Algiers and Paris have been caught in a storm of unprecedented turbulence since Algeria’s independence. While international observers speculate on the root causes of this deterioration, Algerian diplomatic sources based in Paris assert that the crisis was not only foreseeable but had long been anticipated, analyzed, and documented. According to these diplomats, the roots of this rupture run deep, stemming from a deliberate and methodical strategy orchestrated by powerful circles within the very heart of the French state apparatus.

Ignored Warnings

Confidential diplomatic reports, excerpts of which were recently leaked according to El Khabar and Algérie Patriotique, point to a series of warnings issued by Algeria’s embassy in Paris over more than a decade. These documents, addressed to senior authorities in Algiers, detail a range of maneuvers led by what diplomats describe as “hostile circles” within French institutions.

These groups, according to sources, worked systematically to thwart any attempt at rapprochement or normalization between Algeria and France, acting from the shadows through intelligence services (notably the DGSE), key ministries such as the Interior, and through influence in mainstream media. In the eyes of Algerian diplomats, this represented a long-term war of attrition that gradually drove the two nations apart.

The Dubious Role of Certain Institutions

At the center of the criticisms voiced by these diplomats lies a deep mistrust of certain international institutions headquartered in France. UNESCO, based in Paris, is singled out for being composed—according to a former Algerian staffer—of nearly 90% French nationals, and currently directed by Audrey Azoulay, daughter of André Azoulay, a senior advisor to the Moroccan monarchy. Many in Algiers perceive a distinct pro-Moroccan bias within the organization, particularly sensitive given Algeria's longstanding rivalry with Morocco over issues such as Western Sahara.

The Arab World Institute (IMA), headed for many years by Jack Lang, is also mentioned. According to Algerian diplomatic sources, the institution has displayed a clear orientation toward Rabat, at the expense of balanced representation of the Arab world. This has, in turn, contributed to Algeria’s marginalization within cultural circles in Paris.

Silenced French Voices

Despite rising tensions, certain French figures have attempted to promote a calm and reasonable discourse concerning bilateral relations. Former Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin, for example, has consistently advocated for a respectful dialogue with Algiers. Historian Benjamin Stora, in his 2021 report on colonial memory, called for an honest acknowledgment of France’s colonial past. Jean-Michel Aphatie, a journalist known for his balanced views, and Michel Bisac, President of the Algerian-French Chamber of Commerce and Industry, also warned against the damaging consequences of deteriorating economic ties.

However, these voices have been systematically sidelined, attacked in the media, or ignored by political decision-makers—feeding the perception in Algeria that France’s policy toward Algiers is dictated by a tightly controlled network resistant to any positive evolution.

A Fracture Algeria Has Embraced

In the face of perceived hostility, Algeria appears to have chosen a strategic path of patience and diversification. Algerian authorities have progressively redefined their geopolitical priorities, multiplying partnerships with countries like China, Turkey, Russia, and Italy, while relegating France to the status of a secondary partner—both economically and diplomatically.

According to Le Soir d’Algérie, this strategic pivot, initiated as early as 2015, gained momentum following what Algeria viewed as deeply offensive remarks by President Emmanuel Macron in 2021 about the so-called “memorial rent” of the Algerian regime. For Algiers, the current rupture is not a diplomatic accident but the culmination of a long, calculated disengagement—one for which France bears primary responsibility.

A Point of No Return? A Prospective Analysis of Algerian–French Relations

The current deterioration in Algerian–French relations is not the product of chance, but the result of a slow-burning dynamic marked by mutual distrust, misunderstandings, and acts of real or perceived hostility. Algerian diplomatic reports make it clear that Algiers was never under any illusion about the intentions of certain elements within the French state. The question now is whether a moment of clarity can reopen channels of dialogue—or whether the fracture has become permanent.

As tensions continue to mount, the future of Algerian–French relations appears increasingly shaped by rupture. Several converging trends support this trajectory: on one side, the growing radicalization of French political and media discourse toward Algeria; on the other, a rising wave of Algerian nationalism that is leading to cultural, economic, and symbolic disengagement from the former colonial power.

France’s Identity Shift

The rise of identity-focused narratives in French public discourse—centered around themes like “uncontrolled immigration,” “separatism,” and “colonial repentance”—has transformed Algeria into a domestic political issue. The 2027 presidential elections are already shaping up as a battleground for nationalist posturing, with right- and far-right candidates proposing increasingly hardline stances on colonial memory, migration, and bilateral cooperation.

In Paris, this shift is often framed as an attempt to “reestablish a relationship of equals.” However, in Algiers, it is widely seen as a constant affront to Algerian sovereignty—further alienating a public already skeptical of French intentions and deepening mistrust of any renewed partnership.

Algerian Nationalism: A Strategic Response

In response to this perceived hostility, Algeria has not adopted a defensive posture, but a calculated and assertive one. The new Algerian nationalism is not purely ideological or reactive; it is structured and driven by deliberate policy decisions.

• Economically, Algeria is bolstering ties with China, Italy, Turkey, and sub-Saharan Africa. The retreat of French firms such as TotalEnergies, Renault, and Sanofi, in the face of competition from Chinese and Turkish rivals, reflects a deeper strategic realignment.

• Culturally, signs are equally clear: reforms to introduce English earlier in the education system, reinforcement of Tamazight as a national language, support for domestic media and cultural production, and promotion of national heritage. The era in which Paris was seen as a cultural horizon is over. Today, Algiers looks to Istanbul, Doha, Beijing, and Moscow.

• Diplomatically, Algeria is deepening its alliances within the BRICS group—hoping to join its core membership—and reinforcing its presence on the African stage. This “Global South” diplomacy is designed to sever reliance on the Eurocentric, and specifically Francocentric, frameworks of international cooperation.

Future Scenarios: Prolonged Rupture or Conditional Reconciliation?

In the short and medium term, three possible scenarios emerge:

1. Prolonged Rupture
   If current positions harden further, diplomatic relations could enter a long phase of freeze, reminiscent of Algeria’s standoff with Morocco. Economic cooperation would be marginalized, and cultural and academic exchanges would cease. Algerian youth would turn their backs on France as a model, forging deeper connections with alternative global partners.

2. Pragmatic Reconciliation
   Under pressure from economic stakeholders—particularly French businesses fearing the loss of a vital market—some within France’s political class might push for de-escalation. However, this scenario would require a complete overhaul of the French narrative toward Algeria, rooted in mutual respect, historical clarity, and the end of patronizing interference. While desirable to many, it seems unlikely in the short term given France’s current political climate.

3. Cold Competition
   Without a formal rupture, Algiers and Paris might settle into a cold coexistence: minimal cooperation, formal diplomacy, but ongoing rivalry in regional matters such as the Sahel, Libya, and energy. This competition will also extend into diaspora communities, where the battle over narratives and identity is already underway.

Conclusion: A Chapter Closes

France and Algeria appear to be moving along increasingly divergent paths. Far from the myth of a “special relationship,” the current state of affairs demands a sober reassessment: the two nations now have deeply conflicting interests, worldviews, and strategic priorities. Writing a new chapter will require far more than minor diplomatic adjustments—it will demand a fundamental shift in mindset.

---

By Belgacem Merbah

---

Sources:

• El Khabar – “Algerian Diplomats in Paris Had Warned,” March 2025

• Algérie Patriotique – Confidential Diplomatic Reports, April 2025

• Le Soir d’Algérie – “When Algiers Turns the Page on Paris,” February 2025

• Le Monde – “Stora, de Villepin, Aphatie: Silenced Voices of Reason,” January 2025

• RFI – “Franco-Algerian Relations Put to the Test,” December 2024