The France-Algeria Crisis: Possible Scenarios and Geostrategic Implications in the Mediterranean and Africa

Relations between France and Algeria are experiencing unprecedented tensions, particularly due to France’s support for Morocco’s sovereignty over Western Sahara. Algeria perceives this stance as a direct threat to its strategic interests in North Africa and the Sahel. However, this crisis is not limited to the Western Sahara issue; it also extends to economic cooperation, military alliances, and regional influence in Africa.

This article aims to analyze the possible trajectories of the France-Algeria crisis by examining potential scenarios and their short-, medium-, and long-term geopolitical and geostrategic consequences. The analysis is based on academic sources and research studies to assess the factors driving this crisis and its broader implications for power dynamics in the Mediterranean and Africa.

1. Geopolitical Context of the France-Algeria Crisis

1.1. Western Sahara: The Core of the Dispute

Algeria has maintained a consistent position on the Western Sahara issue for decades, supporting the Polisario Front and advocating for the implementation of UN resolutions that call for a self-determination referendum (United Nations, 2023). France, on the other hand, has increasingly aligned itself with Morocco, both diplomatically and through economic and military partnerships (El Qadim, 2023).

Many analysts argue that France’s stance is not neutral; rather, it is motivated by geopolitical and economic considerations, particularly the need to maintain its strategic partnership with Morocco, a key ally in North Africa (Zoubir, 2019). Algeria, in turn, sees this as a direct challenge to the regional balance of power and a threat to its role as a key player in the Maghreb.

1.2. Competition for Influence in Africa

Beyond the Western Sahara issue, another major factor fueling tensions is the competition for influence in Africa, particularly in the Sahel. After decades of French dominance in its former colonies, Algeria has been expanding its diplomatic and military presence, taking advantage of France’s declining influence in several African countries (Boukhars, 2022).

The Sahel region holds strategic importance for Algeria, which views it as an extension of its national security, particularly given the rise of terrorism and political instability in Mali, Niger, and Chad. Meanwhile, France is attempting to maintain its traditional influence, but its policies face increasing resistance, as seen in the growing anti-French sentiment in countries like Mali and Burkina Faso (Cherkaoui, 2023).

2. Possible Scenarios for the Evolution of the Crisis

2.1. Scenario 1: Diplomatic De-escalation (Unlikely in the Short Term)

In this scenario, both countries would seek to ease tensions by reopening diplomatic channels and potentially reaching a compromise on key issues.

Factors That Could Lead to This Scenario:

• A mutual interest in avoiding an escalation that could harm economic ties.
• The necessity of cooperation in areas such as counterterrorism and migration control.
• Pressure from international actors, particularly the European Union, to encourage diplomatic rapprochement.

Impacts:

• Short-term: A reduction in diplomatic tensions but without addressing the core disagreements.
• Medium-term: The resumption of limited cooperation in sectors like energy and security.
• Long-term: A fragile balance, with underlying tensions that could resurface depending on political changes.

⚠️ While this scenario is ideal, it remains unlikely given the entrenched positions of both sides and the lack of political will to make concessions.

2.2. Scenario 2: Gradual Decoupling and Realignment of Alliances

If France continues its pro-Moroccan stance, Algeria may take steps to sever its dependence on France and strengthen partnerships with alternative powers such as Russia, China, and Turkey.

Potential Algerian Actions:

• Reducing economic cooperation with France, particularly in energy and investment sectors.
• Strengthening strategic partnerships with Moscow, Beijing, and Ankara.
• Increasing its role in the Sahel to counterbalance French influence.

Impacts:

• Short-term: A decline in economic and diplomatic relations.
• Medium-term: The progressive marginalization of France in Algeria, while Russia and China gain ground (Katz, 2023).
• Long-term: A fundamental shift in geopolitical alignments, with Algeria emerging as a key player in a multipolar North Africa.

📌 This scenario is already unfolding, as Algeria has recently intensified military cooperation with Russia and economic engagements with China (Bensaada, 2022).

2.3. Scenario 3: Political and Economic Confrontation

If tensions continue to escalate, Algeria may adopt more aggressive countermeasures that directly impact French interests.

Possible Algerian Retaliatory Actions:

• Restricting gas exports to France, exacerbating Europe’s ongoing energy crisis (IEA, 2023).
• Tightening restrictions on French companies operating in Algeria, such as Total and Renault.
• Boosting support for anti-French movements in Africa, including in the Sahel and New Caledonia.

Impacts:

• Short-term: A sharp deterioration in trade and investment relations.
• Medium-term: Rising diplomatic tensions, possibly leading to a partial or complete breakdown of relations.
• Long-term: France’s loss of influence in North Africa, while Algeria strengthens ties with alternative partners.

🔥 This scenario carries significant risks for both countries but could become reality if the crisis continues to escalate.

2.4. Scenario 4: Intensified Competition in Africa

The confrontation between Algeria and France could extend into Africa, where Algeria seeks to enhance its influence through diplomatic, economic, and security initiatives.

Potential Algerian Strategies:

• Expanding its military and diplomatic presence in the Sahel, challenging France’s traditional role.
• Supporting African governments that oppose French influence, as seen in Mali and Burkina Faso.
• Investing in infrastructure and economic projects to position itself as a reliable partner for African nations.

Impacts:

• Short-term: France’s diminishing influence in key African regions.
• Medium-term: Algeria’s emergence as a primary diplomatic player in Africa.
• Long-term: A shift in power dynamics, with France losing its historical dominance in favor of new alliances led by Algeria, Russia, and China.

📊 This scenario is already materializing, as France faces increasing resistance in Africa while Algeria positions itself as an alternative regional power.

Conclusion

The France-Algeria crisis is shaping up to be a turning point in Mediterranean and African geopolitics. While diplomatic de-escalation remains a theoretical possibility, the more likely outcome is a gradual decoupling, with Algeria forging new alliances and France struggling to maintain its influence.

How this crisis evolves will depend on the strategic choices made by both nations in the coming years. However, one thing is certain: this crisis is reshaping regional power dynamics, with significant consequences for France’s geopolitical standing and Algeria’s role as a rising regional power.

---

References

• Bensaada, M. (2022). Algeria and China: A Growing Strategic Partnership. IFRI Press.
• Boukhars, A. (2022). Algeria’s Strategic Repositioning in the Sahel. Carnegie Endowment.
• Cherkaoui, M. (2023). Geopolitical Shifts in the Sahel: Algeria’s Rising Influence. Brookings Institution.
• El Qadim, N. (2023). France-Morocco Relations and the Sahara Issue: A Historical Perspective. Mediterranean Politics Journal.
• IEA (International Energy Agency). (2023). Natural Gas Market Report.
• Katz, M. (2023). Russia’s Expanding Role in North Africa. Foreign Policy Analysis.
• United Nations. (2023). Resolutions on Western Sahara.
• Zoubir, Y. (2019). The Geopolitics of the Western Sahara Conflict. Routledge.